Monday, September 27, 2010

Comment Sections

Comment sections on news sites should be allowed, but I think they should be regulated by the news site. Offensive or demeaning language should not be allowed in any comment. I understand that for many news sites, the manpower to regulate the posts would cost extra time and money. As far as the the Exponent's not allowing comments, I am not sure how I feel about the situation. The recent publishing of the Sex Position of the Week cartoon created a huge backlash against the paper. If comments were allowed on their website during the immediate onslaught of criticism, the website would have crashed, like Zoe said. I feel like comments should be allowed on the paper's website, but they should be monitored to ensure they are appropriate. But who is to say which comments are appropriate if they border on overly critical and demeaning? Also, anonymous commenting might make the comment board unreadable due to posters' view of invincibility under the anonymous tag. I think the paper should allow comments for some articles just as a trial to see how things go.

Hotseat Response

I think Hotseat is a great idea for large classes here at Purdue. In large lectures, the teacher-student discussion is almost non-existent. With sometimes several hundred people in a class, it is hard for everyone to stay focused on a topic and there is not time for everyone to voice their opinions. In a small class like ours, I think Hotseat would generate a little more discussion between students. There are many students, like myself, who aren't as comfortable speaking in front of the class as others. A discussion board would allow those shy students to voice their opinion on all subjects. However, I feel like our class is a positive discussion environment that could use Hotseat as a supplementary form of discussion among teacher and students.

Monday, September 20, 2010

Second C-SPAN Video



I picked this video because it was concerning the state of our economy on Labor Day. This seems to be a bit of an oxymoron right now because unemployment is very high in the U.S. Nonetheless, I picked the segment of the video where the President rallies the crowd and tries to get them behind him in his agenda of reversing the trickle down effect the Republicans like. These rally speeches have been common of every President, and I figured it would be especially true of Obama because he is a good public speaker to begin with. The crowd behind him claps at his every pause, just like a good background crowd should at a Presidential address. I always look to see what kind of people a President's handlers put behind the President as he speaks. The demographics can be analyzed a number of ways, and I always think the President is trying to relate to those types of people watching at home. Finally, I like that he uses a bit of humor at the end of the segment because this shows he at least hears his opposition, even though he believes in what he is doing. C-SPAN keeps it very simple during this segment of the video, simply putting an identifier at the bottom of the screen that says where the President is and what group he is addressing.

Monday, September 13, 2010

Shirley Sherrod fiasco

This was the first time I had heard of this story. I find it very disheartening that one blogger can create such a stir with a part of a video clip that was available in its entirety. After reading the various links on the class website about the situation, I have a lot of questions about media now. What should consumers believe? Where do we draw the line of consumers and creators? Obviously, that line is continuously blurring. The fact that the blogger influenced government officials at any level is a shame. Why did Vilsack not look past the surface of this story? Tom Vilsack panicked and fired Sherrod publicly, disgracing not only her career but her as a person as well. Where are the government fact checkers to discredit the biased blogger right off the bat, and prevent Vilsack from making a bad decision? How does this happen in this day in age of modern technology and media? Vilsack fell into the media trap and believed what he heard, without doing any investigation of his own. This is what some Americans do as well. Put something on a screen and, guaranteed, at least a few people will assume its true. A government official, for a moment in time, was one of those people.

I think that Howard Kurtz makes some very nice points in his article about the issue, and I believe the toxic atmosphere of the biased news networks will continue to influence whoever will listen, including officials, until something is done. Gatekeepers have fallen by the wayside in order to report on seemingly juicy topics. Hey, wait a second... I can pull a Breitbart. I have a blog. Sorry, but my times up here, I have to get back to maliciously ruining someone's career.

Wednesday, September 1, 2010

C-Span Video


I chose this event and this segment of the event because it deals with various issues of our nation's security and global security in general. First, Mr. Gibbs talks about three major Mexican drug cartels. I found it interesting that this was the first time that a President had went past the June 1 deadline for naming illicit organizations that correlate with the Foreign Narcotics Kingpin Designation Act. Before this video, I did not know there was a Foreign Narcotics Kingpin Designation Act. This shows the urgency that the Administration is feeling in dealing with the cartels. Then, Mr. Gibbs responds to a question about North Korea's nuclear program. North Korea's nuclear program is a threat to everyone, not just the United States. It was no surprise to me that North Korea is being uncooperative in negotiations. I thought it was interesting to hear the White House Press Secretary talk about both situations. I liked what C-SPAN did when introducing the Press Secretary by showing him the foreground with the reporters in the background. This shows what he was looking at when he was speaking, and helps the viewer get a feel for the room. Another thing I liked was the back and forth aspect of the reporter and Mr. Gibbs. The camera was not fixed on Mr. Gibbs the whole time. Every so often, the camera went back to the reporter. I feel like this brings a more personal level to the piece. It shows the back and forth banter that happens at these kinds of events with the speaker and the press. Finally, I liked that the topic of conversation was displayed at the bottom of the screen. This helps the viewer follow the conversation and keep up with the topic.